Cannizzaro caves in: Despite hopes to the contrary, District Attorney Leon Cannizzaro appears to be kowtowing to the rich and powerful. He's decided that hitting someone so hard it puts them in a coma is no worse than jaywalking or spitting on the street.
He's decided Brett Lawson, aide to a Jefferson Parish councilman and son of the Gretna police chief, will only be charged with a municipal misdemeanor of simple battery, instead of a fe
lony.
According to 8th District cops, Lawson punched Jaret Graham, 21, in the head in the 700 block of Canal Street around 3 a.m. on 8.22.09. When police found Graham, he was laying in a pool of blood. He spent 8 days in the hospital, 4 of them in a coma.
But the DA's flak says, "After conducting an extensive and thorough review of all of the evidence in this case--some of which is not available to the public..." that Cannizzaro agrees it's only a case of misdemeanor battery. This from a guy who promised to be tough on crime? And what's this crap about evidence "which is not available to the public"? This was the guy who was going to be so transparent--apparently that's a warning meaning "I'm going to lie to you."
Lawson's attorney says Graham, who was in town from Texas for a bachelor's party, was "drunk out of his mind" and surveillance tapes showed him "grabbing and inappropriately touching 2 girls" who were with Lawson. There was no indication Graham left the girls comatose, however.
So now we've got Cannizzaro on something less than a white horse, wearing less than a white hat. Let's hope he can find someway to redeem himself in the eyes of the public which put so much hope in him.
Oops, wrong guys: Cannizzaro also refused--without explanation--to prosecute the guys cops were sure held up Buffa's Bar & Lounge and St. Charles Bar & Billiards this summer:
- Buffa's: Darwin Hunter, 27, turned himself into 8th District NOPD headqu
arters on 8.5.09 after a warrant was issued for his arrest in the armed robbery of the bar at Esplanade Avenue and Burgundy Street on 7.31.09. The warrant was based on a photo line-up Det. Willie Jenkins showed to people at the bar.
Hunter, who has a long criminal history is a pretty distinctive dude, what with the tattooed cross on the bridge of his nose; whether patrons of a dimly lit bar are the best observers is debatable.
But because they "positively identified" him, Hunter sat in OPP on $160,000 bond for nearly 3 months before being released.
- St. Charles Bar: Travis Chapuis, 24, was arrested by 8th District Det. Maggie Darling for a robbery at the bar at 736 St. Charles Ave. on 8.5.09, the second robbery there in a month.
There's no indication what led the detective to Chapuis, but it wasn't good enough for the DA. But Chapuis spent over 2 months locked up in OPP on the charge, in lieu of a $150,000 bond.
Here's how Chapuis describes his ordeal, in his own words: "Hi an hello thi
s is Travis Chapuis the acused robber of the 736 St. Charles bar &tavern it is ashame that the police and the juges are not doing there job putting inocent people behind bars with no hard evidence so that means I could call the police and tell them that somebody robbed me at gun point an I just pick somebody I dont kie an they will have to spend 60/120 day or longer depending on if there convicted or not this does not seem like justice it seems like you put a blind fold around my eyes and shot me in the chest my face an name is all over the computer saying I did something I didn't do I've been cleared of all charges why havent ya'll put that in your little story I would rather you asked me my side of what happend and what I went through during the time I spent in jail there or so many people in jail for things they didn't do but there is no justice for them I met a lot of people during my time in jail some guilty some inocent how would you feel if someone said you did something you didn't do an you had to sit in jail for it what would your reaction be I lost time with my family my children have grown so much Ihave missed so much that I cant get back an no one can make that right the system is rey screwd up please post a new comment that I have been cleared of all charges."
Others let go: Cannizzaro has been better about it than his predecessors, but he still occasionally nolle prosses some cases, or just flat out refuses to prosecute them. It would be nice if there was some explanation of why:
- Pursesnatching again
st Lenard Legania, 24, was nolle prossed 10.13.09. Legania was accused of being one of 3 black guys who robbed another black man of his coin purse as he sat on his stoop at St. Ann and Dauphine streets late last year.
- Aggravated battery against Shonede Kornbacher, 38, was nolle prossed 10.27.09. He was a
ccused of going after a "friend" who was walking in the 600 block of N. Rampart Street in May with a baseball bat. When the friend disarmed him of the bat, Kornbacher allegedly pulled out a knife and stabbed his friend.
- Charges of aggravated assault, extortion and criminal damage of property again
st Joseph K. Allen, 43, were refused on 10.22.09. Hard to tell what this case was really about, but the police report said the victim was walking near St. Ann and Bourbon streets early one morning in May when he bumped into Allen, a stranger. They got into an argument and Allen allegedly pulled a knife and pointed it toward the victim in a threatening manner. The victim fled but Allen allegedly chased him down--until the police caught Allen.
Others guilty as charged, or nearly so: Most of the convictions come from defendants pleading guilty to the charge against them--often after it has been reduced to something less severe:
- Joseph A. Davis, 18, had several run-ins with the law in the last 6 mon
ths, but has managed to elude serious jail time.
He allegedly grabbed money from a customer in a business in the 500 block of Bourbon Street on 5.24.09. Then on 5.29.09 he was the guy who allegedly grabbed a cellphone from a tourist snapping pictures with it in the 600 block of Bourbon Street. Another incident on 8.8.09, for which there are no details, netted him another simple robbery charge.
But in the first case, he was allowed to plead guilty to attempted theft of less than $300. Judge Karen Herman gave him a 6-month suspended sentence.
In the second case, Judge Darryl Derbigny gave him a 2-year suspended sentence after he pled guilty to simple robbery.
So, despite the trend, Joseph A Davis walks among us--hang on to your money.
- Byron Asmore, 46, on the other hand, got 7 years in prison from Judge La
urie White for pursesnatching when he pled guilty after the DA agreed not to charge him as a career criminal.
He allegedly grabbed the purse of an Asian tourist at Canal Street and Convention Center Boulevard last April.
- Nicholas Duplessis (right), 24, and Charles Roy (left), 20, each received a 7-year suspended sente

nce from Judge Robin Pittman after they pled guilty to simple robbery.
They were arrested last July after they were identified as part of a 4-man gang who accosted a white guy at N. Rampart and St. Louis streets, grabbing his money after he obliged their request for a cigarette and pulled a pack of smokes from his pocket along with his cash.
- Purnell Madison, 62, was sentenced to 10 years in prison by Judge Lynda Van D
avis as a multiple offender after pleading guilty to pursesnatching.
He was charged after he grabbed a woman's purse last April as she was walking in the 100 block of S. Peters Street.
- Jarred C. Simmon
s Jr., 18, was given a 3-year suspended sentence by Judge Ben Willard after pleading guilty to attempted simple robbery.
He was arrested last April after he asked a woman for some money in the 700 block of Royal Street and then tried grabbing her purse when she refused.
- Keri Ansley, 25, was senten
ced to a year in jail by Judge Julian Parker after she pled guilty to aggravated battery for stabbing her boyfriend several times at 925 Common St. in July.
- Raymond Taylor, 41, was given a 6-month suspended sentence by Magistrate Rudy G
orrell after finding him guilty of aggravated assault.
Taylor was arrested after he got into an argument with a friend at Iberville and N. Peters streets last May and then pulled a pistol and pointed it at him.
- Romeo Alvarez, 21, was given a 2-year suspended sent
ence by Judge Karen Herman after he pled guilty to illegal use of a weapon.
Alvarez was arrested after cops responding to a call of gunshots in the 700 block of Kerlerec Street found Alvarez firing a handgun into the air.
- Aubrey Young, 23, didn't know when he was well off. Back in November last
year he got a 2-year suspended sentence for a charge of possession with intent to distribute marijuana that was whittled down to possession of marijuana.
So he was out on the streets when 8th District officers Anthony Bakewell and Brandon Ludwig came upon him involved in "suspicious activity" at Iberville and Decatur streets 3.19.09 which, they said, amounted to distribution of marijuana.
This time the charge was reduced to possession with intent to distribute and Judge Darryl Derbigny imposed a 10-year suspended sentence.
But, thanks to Judge Robin Pittman, Young's probation on his previous 2-year sentence was revoked and he's doing the time in OPP.
- Brandon Roussell, 18, was given a 3-year suspended sentence by Judge Karen Her
man (doesn't anybody do time for the crime any more?) after he pled guilty to 2 charges of simple robbery.
Roussell, who was only 17 at the time, and 2 of his buddies were originally charged with 1st-degree robbery after they allegedly jumped 2 guys in the 1400 block of Canal Street back in April and robbed them after implying they had a guy. His 2 accomplices got only 4-month sentences for their role in the crime, equaling the time they spent in jail awaiting trial.
* * *
As always, your comments and suggestions are welcome at NOcrimeline@gmail.com
Thom Kahler